Game 3 was played by Theodor Lichtenhein (white) and
Paul Morphy (black) in 1857.
(Mary is white and Sam is black. Game 5 in the story.)
descriptive notation

White        Black

1. e4         e5

2. Nf3       Nc6

3. d4         exd4

4. Bc4       Nf6

5. e5         d5

6. Bb5      Ne4

7. Nxd4    Bd7

White           Black

8. Nxc6       bxc6

9. Bd3         Bc5

10. Bxe4      Qh4

11. Qe2       dxe4

12. Be3       Bg4

13. Qc4       Bxe3

14. g3         Qd8

White         Black

15. fxe3      Qd1+

16. Kf2       Qf3+

17. Kg1       Bh3

18. Qxc6+    Kf8

19. Qxa8+    Ke7

  Resigns

 

Game 2 Game 4
Master Chess Games chapter 9